Tax Evasion in Pakistan: A Hidden Crisis Undermining the Nation

Introduction

Tax evasion is a persistent and deeply rooted problem in Pakistan that significantly undermines the country’s economic stability and development. Despite having a population of over 240 million, Pakistan struggles with a narrow tax base, where only a small percentage of individuals and businesses contribute to the national revenue. According to the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), tax-to-GDP ratio remains critically low — around 9% — compared to the global average of over 15%, placing Pakistan among the countries with the lowest tax compliance.

This blog explores the causes, methods, impacts, and potential solutions to tax evasion in Pakistan, aiming to highlight the urgent need for reforms and stronger enforcement to ensure a fair and functional taxation system.

What is Tax Evasion?

Tax evasion refers to the illegal practice of deliberately avoiding paying taxes, typically by misrepresenting income, inflating deductions, hiding money in offshore accounts, or conducting business in the informal economy. Unlike tax avoidance — which involves legal ways of reducing tax liability — tax evasion is a punishable offense under Pakistani law.

Common Methods of Tax Evasion in Pakistan

1. Under-reporting Income: Many individuals and businesses under-report their earnings, especially in the retail and service sectors. Cash-based transactions often go unrecorded, making it difficult for authorities to assess the actual income.
2. Fake Invoicing: Businesses often generate fake invoices or manipulate purchase and sales records to reduce taxable income.
3. Benami Transactions: Properties and assets are sometimes held in the names of relatives or fictitious individuals to evade taxation.
4. Non-filing of Returns: A large number of eligible taxpayers simply do not file their tax returns. The FBR has made efforts to broaden the tax net, but the gap remains wide.
5. Use of Offshore Accounts: Wealthy individuals often move their funds abroad to avoid taxation, as revealed in several international leaks such as the Panama and Pandora Papers.

Root Causes of Tax Evasion

1. Lack of Trust in Government: Citizens are often reluctant to pay taxes due to perceptions of corruption, poor governance, and lack of transparency in how tax revenues are used.
2. Weak Enforcement Mechanisms: The FBR and other tax authorities suffer from capacity constraints, outdated systems, and limited access to data, making it difficult to detect and penalise evaders.
3. Informal Economy: A significant portion of Pakistan’s economy remains undocumented. Informal businesses operate without registration, making it easy to evade taxes.
4. Political Influence and Corruption: Politically connected individuals and powerful business groups often influence tax authorities, leading to selective enforcement and tax amnesties.
5. Complex Tax Laws: Complicated procedures and unclear regulations discourage voluntary compliance and create opportunities for manipulation.

Impact of Tax Evasion

1. Revenue Shortfall: Tax evasion deprives the government of essential revenue, limiting its ability to invest in infrastructure, health, education, and social welfare.
2. Increased Burden on Honest Taxpayers: When a small portion of the population pays taxes, they end up shouldering a disproportionate burden, which further discourages compliance.
3. Widening Inequality: Wealthy individuals and large corporations often evade taxes, while lower-income groups bear the brunt of indirect taxation, leading to social and economic inequality.
4. Dependence on External Debt: Due to insufficient domestic revenue, Pakistan relies heavily on foreign loans and aid, leading to rising debt and economic vulnerability.

Efforts Made by the Government

Pakistan has taken several steps to address tax evasion, including:

• Documentation Initiatives: Efforts to digitise the economy, such as mandatory POS systems and CNIC requirements for large transactions, aim to bring undocumented sectors into the tax net.
• NADRA https://id.nadra.gov.pk/e-id/  and FBR https://fbr.gov.pk/ Collaboration: Integration of citizen data from various sources has enabled better profiling of potential taxpayers.
• Tax Amnesty Schemes: Although controversial, these schemes have been used to encourage tax evaders to declare hidden assets by offering reduced penalties.
• Track and Trace Systems: These have been introduced in high-risk sectors like tobacco and sugar to monitor production and sales more accurately.

Despite these initiatives, enforcement remains inconsistent, and public trust in the system is still weak.

The Way Forward

1. Simplify Tax Laws: A more transparent and simplified tax system can reduce loopholes and improve compliance.
2. Incentivize Compliance: Offering rewards or benefits for honest taxpayers can encourage a culture of tax responsibility.
3. Public Awareness Campaigns: Educating citizens on the importance of taxes and how they benefit the country can foster a sense of civic duty.
4. Strengthen FBR: Investing in modern technology, capacity building, and independent oversight of tax institutions can improve detection and enforcement.
5. Political Will: Strong political commitment is essential to break the cycle of elite capture and ensure equitable taxation.

Conclusion

Tax evasion in Pakistan is not just an economic issue — it is a moral and structural crisis that affects the very fabric of society. For Pakistan to prosper and reduce its dependence on external aid, a fair and efficient tax system is imperative. While reforms have begun, much more needs to be done to restore public trust, close loopholes, and build a tax culture based on equity and accountability.

A tax-just Pakistan is not only possible — it is necessary for the nation’s survival and progress.

For Tax services and updates, subscribe to https://taxaccountant.pk/